|
July
22, 2002
Dear
Clients and Friends:
Our
belief that a widespread investor capitulation would not be necessary
for the stock market to bottom was incorrect. The underlying fundamentals
were improving and many stocks and investors had not participated
in the great technology bubble, but hindsight is 20/20. Up until
June, we managed to avoid most of the damage from this bear market,
which began in early 2000. Now, with stocks plunging, investors
are panicking and few stocks have been spared. Here is an update
on our thinking.
Our
expectations are separated into shorter-term and longer-term time
horizons. Over the long-term-stock market returns correlate to earnings
growth, and both America and its economy are fundamentally healthy.
As Barton Biggs suggested in his July 7 investment overview, it
hasn't paid to bet against America. No doubt there were substantial
excesses in the stock market, and a significant amount of wrongdoing
by Corporate America, but there have been excesses and scandals
before, and America has always had, in Biggs' words, "an incredible
capacity to heal and reform itself." That has not changed in
our opinion.
What
has changed in our longer-term outlook is valuation. With the recent
plunge in equity prices, stocks are now relatively fairly valued.
Where previously we talked about long-term stock-market returns
reverting to the norm by means of a series of less-than-average
return years, that process has occurred much more quickly than we
expected. Now, with valuations having come down, we can look forward
toward more positive returns over coming years. In other words,
as the stock market declines, we are becoming more bullish about
the long term.
However, we are unsure about how the shorter term may play out.
A bottom could be near, but we do not think the give-up stage is
over yet. One possible scenario is a sharp final spike of panic
selling. That might actually be the least painful outcome, as it
would happen quickly and then be over. An alternative scenario could
be more drawn out, with occasional rallies that fail and give way,
each time, to lower lows until, finally, the bottom is made. But
the end result should be the same. We suspect the bottom will be
reached over the next few months.
Are
there legitimate risks? Yes: additional corporate malfeasance, terrorism,
of course, and the possibility that the stock market could be a
self-fulfilling forecast of a weakening economy by causing the consumer
to slow spending. But much of the potential risk is already priced
into the market. Our bottom line is that it is too late to sell,
but perhaps still too early to aggressively invest cash reserves.
So
we are not bearish, but we are not yet short-term bullish either.
In our opinion, we are in the 8th or 9th inning of a secular bear
market that began in early 2000. And it is our very strong belief
that, while we may not yet be at the final bottom, investment returns
from these levels should be quite favorable. Investors who choose
to hold good stocks at good prices should be well rewarded over
time.
Please
do not hesitate to call upon us with your thoughts or questions.
Lewis
H. Katcher, CFA
Stephen P. Yeatman
John A. Stratton, CPA, CFA
|